diff --git a/worlds/stardew_valley/data/items.csv b/worlds/stardew_valley/data/items.csv
index a3096cf7..9ecb2ba3 100644
--- a/worlds/stardew_valley/data/items.csv
+++ b/worlds/stardew_valley/data/items.csv
@@ -735,26 +735,26 @@ id,name,classification,groups,mod_name
 10007,Tractor Garage,useful,,Tractor Mod
 10008,Woods Obelisk,progression,,DeepWoods
 10009,Spell: Clear Debris,progression,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
-10010,Spell: Till,useful,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
+10010,Spell: Till,progression,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
 10011,Spell: Water,progression,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
 10012,Spell: Blink,progression,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
-10013,Spell: Evac,useful,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
-10014,Spell: Haste,useful,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
+10013,Spell: Evac,progression,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
+10014,Spell: Haste,progression,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
 10015,Spell: Heal,progression,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
-10016,Spell: Buff,useful,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
+10016,Spell: Buff,progression,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
 10017,Spell: Shockwave,progression,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
 10018,Spell: Fireball,progression,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
 10019,Spell: Frostbolt,progression,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
 10020,Spell: Teleport,progression,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
-10021,Spell: Lantern,useful,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
+10021,Spell: Lantern,progression,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
 10022,Spell: Tendrils,progression,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
-10023,Spell: Photosynthesis,useful,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
+10023,Spell: Photosynthesis,progression,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
 10024,Spell: Descend,progression,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
 10025,Spell: Meteor,progression,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
-10026,Spell: Bloodmana,useful,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
-10027,Spell: Lucksteal,useful,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
+10026,Spell: Bloodmana,progression,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
+10027,Spell: Lucksteal,progression,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
 10028,Spell: Spirit,progression,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
-10029,Spell: Rewind,useful,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
+10029,Spell: Rewind,progression,MAGIC_SPELL,Magic
 10030,Pendant of Community,progression,,DeepWoods
 10031,Pendant of Elders,progression,,DeepWoods
 10032,Pendant of Depths,progression,,DeepWoods
diff --git a/worlds/stardew_valley/mods/logic/magic_logic.py b/worlds/stardew_valley/mods/logic/magic_logic.py
index 99482b06..662ff3ac 100644
--- a/worlds/stardew_valley/mods/logic/magic_logic.py
+++ b/worlds/stardew_valley/mods/logic/magic_logic.py
@@ -8,7 +8,7 @@ from ...mods.mod_data import ModNames
 from ...stardew_rule import StardewRule, False_
 from ...strings.ap_names.skill_level_names import ModSkillLevel
 from ...strings.region_names import MagicRegion
-from ...strings.spells import MagicSpell
+from ...strings.spells import MagicSpell, all_spells
 
 
 class MagicLogicMixin(BaseLogicMixin):
@@ -27,7 +27,8 @@ class MagicLogic(BaseLogic[Union[RegionLogicMixin, ReceivedLogicMixin, HasLogicM
     def can_use_altar(self) -> StardewRule:
         if ModNames.magic not in self.options.mods:
             return False_()
-        return self.logic.region.can_reach(MagicRegion.altar)
+        spell_rule = False_()
+        return self.logic.region.can_reach(MagicRegion.altar) & self.logic.received_any(*all_spells)
 
     def has_any_spell(self) -> StardewRule:
         if ModNames.magic not in self.options.mods:
diff --git a/worlds/stardew_valley/strings/spells.py b/worlds/stardew_valley/strings/spells.py
index ef5545c5..4b246c17 100644
--- a/worlds/stardew_valley/strings/spells.py
+++ b/worlds/stardew_valley/strings/spells.py
@@ -1,22 +1,30 @@
+all_spells = []
+
+
+def spell(name: str) -> str:
+    all_spells.append(name)
+    return name
+
+
 class MagicSpell:
-    clear_debris = "Spell: Clear Debris"
-    till = "Spell: Till"
-    water = "Spell: Water"
-    blink = "Spell: Blink"
-    evac = "Spell: Evac"
-    haste = "Spell: Haste"
-    heal = "Spell: Heal"
-    buff = "Spell: Buff"
-    shockwave = "Spell: Shockwave"
-    fireball = "Spell: Fireball"
-    frostbite = "Spell: Frostbolt"
-    teleport = "Spell: Teleport"
-    lantern = "Spell: Lantern"
-    tendrils = "Spell: Tendrils"
-    photosynthesis = "Spell: Photosynthesis"
-    descend = "Spell: Descend"
-    meteor = "Spell: Meteor"
-    bloodmana = "Spell: Bloodmana"
-    lucksteal = "Spell: Lucksteal"
-    spirit = "Spell: Spirit"
-    rewind = "Spell: Rewind"
+    clear_debris = spell("Spell: Clear Debris")
+    till = spell("Spell: Till")
+    water = spell("Spell: Water")
+    blink = spell("Spell: Blink")
+    evac = spell("Spell: Evac")
+    haste = spell("Spell: Haste")
+    heal = spell("Spell: Heal")
+    buff = spell("Spell: Buff")
+    shockwave = spell("Spell: Shockwave")
+    fireball = spell("Spell: Fireball")
+    frostbite = spell("Spell: Frostbolt")
+    teleport = spell("Spell: Teleport")
+    lantern = spell("Spell: Lantern")
+    tendrils = spell("Spell: Tendrils")
+    photosynthesis = spell("Spell: Photosynthesis")
+    descend = spell("Spell: Descend")
+    meteor = spell("Spell: Meteor")
+    bloodmana = spell("Spell: Bloodmana")
+    lucksteal = spell("Spell: Lucksteal")
+    spirit = spell("Spell: Spirit")
+    rewind = spell("Spell: Rewind")