diff --git a/Mystery.py b/Mystery.py
index 349f7632..c4ca1f03 100644
--- a/Mystery.py
+++ b/Mystery.py
@@ -538,13 +538,13 @@ def roll_settings(weights: dict, plando_options: typing.Set[str] = frozenset(("b
             if option_name in weights:
                 setattr(ret, option_name, option.from_any(get_choice(option_name, weights)))
             else:
-                setattr(ret, option_name, option.from_any(option.default))
+                setattr(ret, option_name, option(option.default))
     elif ret.game == "Minecraft":
         for option_name, option in Options.minecraft_options.items():
             if option_name in weights:
                 setattr(ret, option_name, option.from_any(get_choice(option_name, weights)))
             else:
-                setattr(ret, option_name, option.from_any(option.default))
+                setattr(ret, option_name, option(option.default))
     else:
         raise Exception(f"Unsupported game {ret.game}")
     return ret