diff --git a/Mystery.py b/Mystery.py
index a546233e..021a1c9e 100644
--- a/Mystery.py
+++ b/Mystery.py
@@ -216,7 +216,7 @@ def roll_settings(weights):
         if item.startswith(('Progressive ', 'Small Key ', 'Rupee', 'Piece of Heart', 'Boss Heart Container', 'Sanctuary Heart Container', 'Arrow', 'Bombs ', 'Bomb ', 'Bottle')) and isinstance(itemvalue, int):
             for i in range(int(get_choice(item, inventoryweights))):
                 startitems.append(item)
-        if get_choice(item, inventoryweights):
+        elif get_choice(item, inventoryweights):
             startitems.append(item)
     if glitches_required in ['no_logic'] and 'Pegasus Boots' not in startitems:
         startitems.append('Pegasus Boots')