diff --git a/worlds/overcooked2/Overcooked2Levels.py b/worlds/overcooked2/Overcooked2Levels.py
index aac9ea0c..4c14a8f8 100644
--- a/worlds/overcooked2/Overcooked2Levels.py
+++ b/worlds/overcooked2/Overcooked2Levels.py
@@ -87,6 +87,31 @@ class Overcooked2Dlc(Enum):
 
         return []
 
+    def exclusive_items(self) -> List[str]:
+        """Returns list of items exclusive to this DLC"""
+        if self == Overcooked2Dlc.SURF_N_TURF:
+            return ["Bellows"]
+        if self == Overcooked2Dlc.CAMPFIRE_COOK_OFF:
+            return ["Wood"]
+        if self == Overcooked2Dlc.NIGHT_OF_THE_HANGRY_HORDE:
+            return ["Coal Bucket"]
+        if self == Overcooked2Dlc.CARNIVAL_OF_CHAOS:
+            return ["Faster Condiment/Drink Switch"]
+        if self == Overcooked2Dlc.SEASONAL:
+            return ["Wok Wheels"]
+
+        return []
+
+ITEMS_TO_EXCLUDE_IF_NO_DLC = [
+    "Wood",
+    "Coal Bucket",
+    "Bellows",
+    "Coin Purse",
+    "Wok Wheels",
+    "Lightweight Backpack",
+    "Faster Condiment/Drink Switch",
+    "Calmer Unbread",
+]
 
 class Overcooked2GameWorld(Enum):
     ONE = 1
diff --git a/worlds/overcooked2/__init__.py b/worlds/overcooked2/__init__.py
index 8cce1870..0fafdd1e 100644
--- a/worlds/overcooked2/__init__.py
+++ b/worlds/overcooked2/__init__.py
@@ -4,7 +4,7 @@ from typing import Callable, Dict, Any, List, Optional
 from BaseClasses import ItemClassification, CollectionState, Region, Entrance, Location, RegionType, Tutorial
 from worlds.AutoWorld import World, WebWorld
 
-from .Overcooked2Levels import Overcooked2Level, Overcooked2GenericLevel
+from .Overcooked2Levels import Overcooked2Level, Overcooked2GenericLevel, ITEMS_TO_EXCLUDE_IF_NO_DLC
 from .Locations import Overcooked2Location, oc2_location_name_to_id, oc2_location_id_to_name
 from .Options import overcooked_options, OC2Options, OC2OnToggle
 from .Items import item_table, Overcooked2Item, item_name_to_id, item_id_to_name, item_to_unlock_event, item_frequencies
@@ -259,11 +259,16 @@ class Overcooked2World(World):
         # filler = list()
         # progression = list()
         for item_name in item_table:
+            if not self.options["ShuffleLevelOrder"] and item_name in ITEMS_TO_EXCLUDE_IF_NO_DLC:
+                # skip DLC items if no DLC
+                continue
+
             if not self.options["IncludeHordeLevels"] and item_name in ["Calmer Unbread", "Coin Purse"]:
-                # skip items which are irrelevant to the seed
+                # skip horde-specific items if no horde levels
                 continue
             
             if not self.options["KevinLevels"] and item_name.startswith("Kevin"):
+                # skip kevin items if no kevin levels
                 continue
 
             if is_item_progression(item_name, self.level_mapping, self.options["KevinLevels"]):
diff --git a/worlds/overcooked2/test/TestOvercooked2.py b/worlds/overcooked2/test/TestOvercooked2.py
index 8f5ea9d4..aad71211 100644
--- a/worlds/overcooked2/test/TestOvercooked2.py
+++ b/worlds/overcooked2/test/TestOvercooked2.py
@@ -3,7 +3,7 @@ import unittest
 from random import Random
 
 from worlds.overcooked2.Items import *
-from worlds.overcooked2.Overcooked2Levels import Overcooked2Level, level_id_to_shortname
+from worlds.overcooked2.Overcooked2Levels import Overcooked2Dlc, Overcooked2Level, level_id_to_shortname, ITEMS_TO_EXCLUDE_IF_NO_DLC
 from worlds.overcooked2.Logic import level_logic, level_shuffle_factory
 from worlds.overcooked2.Locations import oc2_location_name_to_id
 
@@ -139,3 +139,11 @@ class Overcooked2Test(unittest.TestCase):
                 number_of_items += 1
 
         self.assertLessEqual(number_of_items, len(oc2_location_name_to_id), "Too many items (before fillers placed)")
+
+    def testExclusiveItems(self):
+        for dlc in Overcooked2Dlc:
+            for item in dlc.exclusive_items():
+                self.assertIn(item, item_table.keys())
+
+        for item in ITEMS_TO_EXCLUDE_IF_NO_DLC:
+            self.assertIn(item, item_table.keys())